WASHINGTON FAMILY LAW REPORTER

TWELVE MONTH SUBJECT INDEX

VOLUME 23, NUMBERS 1-12

AUGUST 2004-JULY 2005

   

 

SUBSTANTIVE TOPIC INDEX

2000 WSBA Family Section Midyear Conference

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 1)

 

Candidate Filing-Judicial Offices

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 1)

 

Digital Discovery

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 2)

 

Family Law Legislation In Olympia

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 2)

 

In the Children’s Best Interest

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 1)

 

Pension Uncertainty

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 26)

 

Proposed Changes to King County

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 28)

 

Same Sex Marriage, Status Report

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 1)

 

Superior Court Local Rules

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 28)

 

 

CASES IN BRIEF INDEX

AGREEMENT

 

CR2A:   Mediator’s Letter Not Binding

Dregis v. Visco, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 11/29/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 3)

 

ATTORNEY

 

Family Law Attorney Disbarred

In re: Diane L. VanDerbeek, __ Wn.2d __ (11/24/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 4)

 

Questioned Signature Leads to Disbarment

In re Ricardo Guarnero, __Wn.2d __ (7/8/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 3)

 

Standards of Practice: Stock Options Fraught With Controversy

Aubin v. Barton, __ Wn. App. __ (9/27/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 4)

 

Terms For Noncompliance With Local Rule

Marriage of Hess, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 9/20/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 6)

 

CHILD CUSTODY

 

Custody Modification & Name Change: Requests Denied

Ceballas v. Saeteurn, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 10/18/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 7)

 

Custody Modification Petition Falls Short

Thue v. Phanco, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 7/5/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 16)

 

Nonparent Custody and Evaluators

In re Custody of Sierra Helen Brown, __Wn. App. __ (2/10/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 3)

 

CHILD SUPPORT

 

Arvey Applies To Split-Custody, Not Shared Residences

Graham v. Cunliffe, __ Wn. App. __ (11/1/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 11)

 

Bias: Easy to Claim But Difficult to Substantiate

Howard v. Brooks, __ Wn. App. __ (5/10/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 5)

 

Contempt Revisited

Marriage of Seals, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 11/11/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 4)

 

Enforcing A Foreign State Support Order

Owens v. Phillips, __ Wn. App. __ (3/21/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 3)

 

Extrapolated Support Requires Findings

Marriage of Rusch, __ Wn. App. __ (8/23/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 8)

 

Extrapolated Support Reversed

Marriage of Rusch, __Wn. App. __ (8/23/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 4)

 

Extrapolated Support and Post-Secondary Allocation:

Explaining the Rules

Johnson v. Daubert, __ Wn. App. __ (10/25/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 9)

 

Father’s GET’s Credit

Krismer v DeLeon, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 3/7/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 5)

 

Jurisdiction To Modify: 18 But Still In High School

Allbee v. Allred, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished 10/26/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 16)

 

Mandatory Automatic Adjustment: Retroactive Support OK

Stapleton v. Bernards, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 5/3/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 3)

 

Partial Modification of Support

Redditt v. Lee,__Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 4/18/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 3)

 

Setting Support and Fees For Frivolous Appeal

Woodruff-Jones v Jones, __ Wn. App. __ (10/18/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 14)

 

Social Security & Child Support, Plus Restatement

Of Property Principles

Marriage of Lamp, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 10/14/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 15)

 

Support Arrearage:  Equitable Defenses Don’t Apply

Paratore v. Steele, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 10/18/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 13)

 

Support Modification Affirmed, With a Twist

Marriage of Michelson, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 11/22/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 12)

 

DOMESTIC VIOLENCE

 

Eleven Year Protection Order Affirmed

Lundberg v. Zumbrunnen, __Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 6/13/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 3)

 

DISCIPLINE

 

Discipline For Unauthorized Insurance Coverage

Greenen v. WA State Board of Accountancy, __Wn. App. __ (4/12/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 4)

 

EVIDENCE

 

“All Party Consent” Privacy Act Extends To Parents

State v Christensen, __ Wn.2d __ (12/9/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 17)

 

GRANDPARENT VISITATION

 

Grandparent Visitation Statute Unconstitutional

Parentage of C.A.M.A., Appel v. Appel, __ Wn. App. __ (4/7/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 5)

 

GUARDIAN

 

Guardian Testimony Rules Clarified

Guardianship of Loren Stamm, __ Wn. App. __ (6/1/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 5)

 

 

GAL, ‘Expert’ Testimony, Stock Appreciation and IRA Deduction

Marriage of Bishop, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 8/17/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 6)

 

JUDGMENT

 

Support Payments Applied To Interest First

Marriage of Bond, __Wn. App. __ (5/2/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 5)

 

JURISDICTION

 

Jurisdictional Objections Fail, Default Decree and Fees Proper

Marriage of Gunderson, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 10/4/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 20)

 

Jurisdictional Limitations

Marriage of Coyle, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 5/9/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 21)

 

Service of Process: Receipt By Co-Employee OK

Marriage of Tsarbopoulos, __ Wn. App. __ (8/31/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 18)

 

MAINTENANCE

 

Language Limited Maintenance Modification

Irish v. Irish, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 1/18/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 21)

 

Maintenance Challenge Denied

Marriage of Williams, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 1/18/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 22)

 

No Credit Allowed Against Arrearage

Marriage of Pol, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 5/24/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 8)

 

No Maintenance Following Short Term Marriage

Marriage of Haney, __Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 5/24/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 5)

 

Property Characterization & Maintenance

Marriage of Marzetta, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 4/21/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 6)

 

MERETRICIOUS

 

$135,000 For Nine-Year Meretricious Relationship

Soltero v. Wimer, __Wn. App. __ 7/12/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 8)

 

Meretricious Claim Fails

Hobbs v. Bates, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 6/28/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 10)

 

Meretricious, Or Not?

Merritt v. Focose, __ Wn. App. __ (5/25/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 9)

 

Pre-Marriage Meretricious Relationship

Marriage of Bostain, __ Wn. App. __ Unpublished, 5/17/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 10)

 

Property Investments In A Meretricious Relationship

Moseley v. Matilla, __ Wn. App. ___ (Unpublished, 5/16/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 13)

 

PARENTAGE

 

Artificial Insemination & Parentage

Parentage of J.J.K. and D.R.K., __ Wn. App. __ (5/4/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 11)

 

PARENTING

 

Adequate Findings For A Parenting Plan

Marriage of Breitenfeldt, __Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 4/12/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 14)

 

Attorney Fees Awarded For Not Using ADR

Marriage of Windmueller, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 7/13/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 13)

 

Claims Against GAL Dismissed

Custody of D.S., __Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 5/24/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 15)

 

Contempt Affirmed

Marriage of Smasne, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 8/12/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 13)

 

‘Custodial Parent’ Designation Dispute

Marriage of Kimpel, __ Wn. App. __ (7/27/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 12)

 

Defining “Consent” For Custody Modification

Marriage of Smith, __Wn. App. __ (5/2/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 15)

 

Impermissible Modifications and Improper Contempt

Halls v. Arden , __ Wn.Ap __ (Unpublished, 2/8/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 10)

 

No Evidence Of Primary Caregiver Presumption

Marriage of Carmichael , __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 2/10/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 12)

 

Parenting Limitations & Decision-Making Authority

Marriage of Mansour, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 12/17/04)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 9)

 

Parenting Plan Bias Not Evident & Fees For Frivolous Appeal

Marriage of Combs, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 10/14/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 28)

 

Parenting Plan Contempt: Mandatory Attorney Fees and Penalties

Myers v. Myers, __ Wn. App. __ (10/19/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 23)

 

Parenting Plan Controversy

Marriage of Miles, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 9/21/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 23)

 

Parenting Plan Restrictions: Reversed and Remanded

Marriage of Katare, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 12/20/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 25)

 

‘Primary Parent’ Designation Affects Relocation

Parentage of R.F.R., __ Wn. App. __ (7/7/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 12)

 

Sole Custody and Permanent No Contact

Marriage of Diaz, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 2/10/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 13)

 

POST-SECONDARY

 

Filing for Post-Secondary Support

Mesick v.Reardon, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 7/12/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 14)

 

Enforcing Post-Secondary Support

Lamus v. Huff, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 5/10/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 15)

 

PROCEDURE

 

Affidavit of Prejudice Permitted

Marriages of Tye/Tresko, __ Wn. App. __ (5/27/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 23)

 

Challenge To TRS Benefit Division Denied

Lamberta v. Niemi, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 1/19/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page  6)

 

Contempt Ruling Improper

Marriage of Yadav, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 8/23/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 22)

 

CR 59(h) Motion Allowed

Marriage of Wilson , __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 5/4/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 18)

 

CR 60 Motion Fails

Marriage of Dorsey, _- Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 5/24/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 17)

 

CR 60(a) Limitations

Marriage of Leichner, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 7/7/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 24)

 

Default Order Reinstated

Cordero v. Panganiban, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 4/4/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 27)

 

Default Judgment Vacated

Marriage of Caley, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 8/10/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 21)

 

Discovery Sanction Too Severe

Walker v. Vlchek, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 6/1/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 24)

 

Executor’s CR 60 Motion Denied

Marriage of Cundiff, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 6/27/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 25)

 

‘Extraordinary Circumstance’ Not Present

Stobbve v. Singer, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 7/5/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 23)

 

Inadequate Service of Motion to Convert LS Decree

Chai v. Kong, __ Wn. App. __ 7/6/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 16)

 

Inadequate Service Vacates Decree

Marriage of Healey, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 7/5/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 19)

 

Incarceration, Recusal and Jurisdiction

Marriage of Blakely, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 2/8/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 8)

 

Inconsistent Petition Invokes Judicial Estoppel

Marriage of Friend, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 8/23/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 19)

 

Motion to Vacate Fails

Marriage of Styers, __ Wn. App. __ (11/23/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 29)

 

Privilege Applies

Osborne v. LDS, __ Wn. App. __ (6/1/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 17)

 

Psychosexual Evaluations and Expert Testimony

Moore v. Hart, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 7/7/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 18)

 

Relief Beyond Petition’s Request

Brunsman v. Stark, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 4/14/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 23)

 

Remand For Trial

Marriage of Gooch, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 3/30/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 7)

 

Res Judicata Bars Relief

Marriage of MacGibbon, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 7/5/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 23)

 

Revision Standard Of Review

Marriage of Jones, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 5/5/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 21)

 

Revision Time Limit Absolute

Marriage of Sales, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 2/8/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 6)

 

Untimely Request For A New Judge

Keith v. Foshee, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 5/9/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 20)

 

PROPERTY

Characterizing Downpayment For House

Marriage of Fil, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 7/5/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 31)

 

Commingled Inheritance Loses Separate Character

Marriage of Black, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 3/22/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 20)

 

Delayed 40l(k) Transfer Creates Controversy

Marriage of Oscarson, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 8/12/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 26)

 

Dismissal of Meretricious Relationship Claim Warrants Remand

Niemela v. Adderly, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 3/7/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 16)

 

Fixing The Split & Life Insurance

Marriage of Farnsworth, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, No. 5/3/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 32)

 

Home Sale , Or Not

Marriage of Sanai, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 5/2/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 30)

 

Judgment Interest Rate

Marriage of Griswold, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 1/13/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 19)

 

Lien Claim By Divorcing Tenants Upheld

Andries v. Covey, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 3/7/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 20)

 

Limits to Judicial Discretion

Marriage of Kaseburg, __ Wn. App. __ (3/22/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 17)

 

No-Fault Dissolution Affirmed

Marriage of Muhammad, __ Wn.2d __ (3/24/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 14)

 

Post-Decree Redistribution Based Upon Fraud

Marriage of Tucker, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 5/24/04)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 30)

 

Professional Practice Goodwill?

Marriage of Brumback, __ Wn. App. __ (7/8/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 25)

 

Stock Options, Conversion & Damages

Marriage of Kolde, __ Wn.2d __ (2/10/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 15)

 

Tenancy In Common: Troublesome Combination

Mullen v. Swann, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 8/31/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 31)

 

Undistributed Property Creates Later Headaches

Marriage of Miles, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 5/17/05)

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 30)

 

Valuation Report Admitted Without Appraiser Testimony

Marriage of Mathiason, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 8/31/04)

(November 2004-January 2005, Nos. 4-6, page 32)

 

Valuing Uncompensated Community Labor & Imputing Income

Marriage of  Botts, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 6/30/05

(May-July 2005, Nos. 10-12, page 28)

 

RESTRAINTS

 

Hearsay OK in DV

Marriage of Gourley, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 8/9/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 29)

 

Protection Order Affirmed

Snow v. Parker, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 8/9/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 28)

 

Unconstitutional Prior Restraint on Speech

Suggs v. Hamilton , __ Wn.2d __ (7/8/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 28)

 

What Constitutes DV?
Piele v. Piele, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 7/6/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 28)

 

THIRD PARTY

 

Third Party Custody Petition Denied

Marriage of Louk, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 5/15/04)

(August-October 2004, Nos. 1-3, page 30)

 

Third Party Custody: Pleading and Evidence Saves

Incomplete Petition

Potter v. Kirol, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 9/27/04)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 23)

 

Suit Against Therapist Dismissed

Tyner v. Drake, __ Wn. App. __ (3/14/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 24)

 

Witness Immunity

Suit Against Therapist Allowed

Caggiano v. Whitehorn, __ Wn. App. __ (Unpublished, 1/10/05)

(February-April 2005, Nos. 7-9, page 24)